Sunday, 5 February 2012

DIRECT EFFECT


There are a couple of events on the 5th February, which attracted attention.

On the 5th February 1919, United Artists was incorporated as a joint venture by four of the leading figures in early Hollywood: Mary Pickford, Charles Chaplin, Douglas Fairbanks and D.W. Griffith. Each held a 20% stake, with the remaining 20% held by lawyer William Gibbs McAdoo. The idea for the venture originated with Fairbanks, Chaplin, Pickford, and cowboy star William S. Hart a year earlier as they were traveling around the U.S. selling Liberty Bonds to help the World War I effort. Already veterans of Hollywood, the four film stars began to talk of forming their own company to better control their own work as well as their futures. They wanted a direct effect on their own lives.

Douglas Fairbanks, Mary Pickford, Charles Chaplin & D.W. Griffith in 1919

William Gibbs McAdoo
Of more importance to the present day, was the Judgment delivered by the European Court of Justice on the 5th February 1963 in Van Gend en Loos v Nederlandse Administratis der Belastingen  (1963) Case 26/62
The case arose from the reclassification of a chemical, by the Benelux countries, into a customs category entailing higher customs charges. The Court held that this breached a provision of the treaty requiring member states to progressively reduce customs duties between themselves, and continued to rule that the breach was actionable by individuals before national courts and not just by the member states of the Community themselves.
Van Gend en Loos, a postal and transportation company, imported urea-formaldehyde from West Germany to the Netherlands. The Dutch customs authorities charged them a tariff on the import. Van Gend en Loos objected, submitting that the tariff was contrary to EC law. Article 12 of the Treaty of Rome (now replaced by Article 30 TFEU) stated:
"Member States shall refrain from introducing between themselves any new customs duties on imports and exports or any charges having equivalent effect, and from increasing those which they already apply in their trade with each other."

Van Gend en Loos paid the tariff but then sought to retrieve the money in the national court. The national court made a request for a preliminary ruling to the European Court of Justice, asking whether the then Article 12 of the Treaty of Rome conferred rights on the nationals of a member state that they could be enforced in national courts.

The European Court of Justice, delivering its judgment on the 5th February 1963, firmly held that Article 12 was capable of creating personal rights for Van Gend en Loos. In a seminal judgment it gave a wide and purposive interpretation to the Treaty of Rome.
The Community constitutes a new legal order of international law for the benefit of which the states have limited their sovereign rights, albeit within limited fields and the subjects of which comprise not only member states but also their nationals. Independently of the legislation of member states, community law therefore not only imposes obligations on individuals but is also intended to confer upon them rights which become part of their legal heritage. These rights arise not only where they are expressly granted by the treaty, but also by reason of obligations which the treaty imposes in a clearly defined way upon individuals as well as upon the member states and upon the institutions of the community.
—Judgment of the Court of 5th  February 1963.

As a result of this Judgement, the principle of direct effect was established. Direct effect has subsequently been loosened in its application to treaty articles and the ECJ has expanded the principle, holding that it is capable of applying to virtually all of the possible forms of EU legislation, the most important of which are regulations and in certain circumstances to directives.

The European Court of Justice laid down the criteria for establishing direct effect. The provision must:
▪   be clear,
▪   negative,
▪   unconditional,
▪   containing no reservation on the part of the member state, and
▪   not dependent on any national implementing measure.
If these criteria are satisfied, then the right or rights in question can be enforced before national courts. Of course whether or not any particular measure satisfies the criteria is a matter of EU law to be determined by the EU Courts.

What it all means is that a citizen is able to enforce a right granted by European Community legislation against the state. There were two varieties of direct effect: vertical direct effect and horizontal direct effect, the distinction drawn being based on against whom the right is to be enforced.
Vertical direct effect concerns the relationship between EU law and national law - specifically, the state's obligation to ensure its observance and its compatibility with EU law, thereby enabling citizens to rely on it in actions against the state. Horizontal direct effect concerns the relationship between individuals (including companies). If a certain provision of EU law is horizontally directly effective, then citizens are able to rely on it in actions against each other. Directives are usually incapable of being horizontally directly effective due to the fact that they are only enforceable against the state. Certain provisions of the treaties and legislative acts such as regulations are capable of being directly enforced horizontally.

The importance of this is that we, as individual citizens, can maintain some action against the larger European State as well as our own governments. I submit this is not a bad thing.

Saturday, 4 February 2012

RONIN, GOVERNMENT, TESTAMENTS, TREATIES AND FACEBOOK

The 4th February reveals a number of items previously touched upon, in particular the continuing saga of the Chūshingura. (see blog 30th January). It was on the 4th February 1703 that forty-six of the forty-seven Ronin committed seppuku as a result of avenging their master’s death.

Washington's handwritten notes for
the first State of the Union Address, 1790
It was also on the 4th February 1789 that General George Washington was unanimously elected as the first President of the United States by the United States Electoral College. He actually took office on the 30th April 1789.  It wads under his Presidency that the Supreme Court was established, as well as the first executive offices of state, Secretaries of State, Treasury and War; the Postmaster General and the Attorney General. And so it began. The ‘tradition’ of inaugural address and State of the Union Address to the joint houses of congress, began with him.

Tischendorf
On the 4th February 1859 The Codex Sinaiticus is discovered in Egypt. Discovered is not exactly the correct term, rediscovered would be more appropriate.  One of the many Indiana Jones type archeologists of the period, Lobegott Friedrich Constantin (von) Tischendorf, a noted German biblical scholar, located it at the Greek Orthodox Monastery of Mount Sinai on the 4th February 1859. It was his third visit to the area. 

In 1844, he paid his first visit to the convent of Saint Catherine’s Monastery, on Mount Sinai, where he found, in a trash basket, forty-four pages of what was the then oldest known copy of the Septuagint. The monks were using the trash to start fires, Tischendorf horrified, asked if he could have them. He deposited them at the University of Leipzig, under the title of the Codex Friderico-Augustus, a name given in honour of his patron, Frederick Augustus II of Saxony, king of Saxony. The fragments were published in 1846 although he kept the place of discovery a secret. In 1853, he made a second trip to the Syrian monastery but made no new discoveries. He returned a third time in January 1859 under the patronage of Czar Alexander II of Russia to find more of the Codex Frederico-Augustanus or similar ancient Biblical texts. On the 4th  February, the last day of his visit, he was shown a text which he recognized as significant — the Codex Sinaiticus —an Alexandrian text-type manuscript written in the 4th century in uncial letters on parchment. Significant stuff indeed.

And on the 4th February 1945, the Yalta Conference opened at the Livadia Palace in the Crimea. It was here, on this day, only 67 years ago that the so called ‘big three’, Churchill, Roosevelt and Stalin began the carve up of what was left of Europe. It was three months before the actual unconditional surrender by Germany on the 8th May 1945. The outcome of the conference was not brilliant. The performance writing was not at its best.


The "Big Three" at the Yalta Conference, Winston Churchill, Franklin D. Roosevelt and Joseph Stalin. Behind them stand, from the left, Field Marshal Sir Alan Brooke, Fleet Admiral Ernest King, Fleet Admiral William D. Leahy, General of the Army George Marshall, Major General Laurence S. Kuter, General Aleksei Antonov, Vice Admiral Stepan Kucherov, and Admiral of the Fleet Nikolay Kuznetsov.

Key points of the meeting are as follows:
▪   Agreement to the priority of the unconditional surrender of Nazi Germany. After the war, Germany and Berlin would be split into four occupied zones.
▪   Stalin agreed that France might have a fourth occupation zone in Germany and in Austria but it would have to be formed out of the American and British zones.
▪   Germany would undergo demilitarization and denazification.
▪   German reparations were partly to be in the form of forced. The forced labour was to be used to repair damage Germany inflicted on its victims.
▪   Creation of a reparation council which would be located in the Soviet Union.
▪   The status of Poland was discussed. It was agreed to reorganize the communist Provisional Government of the Republic of Poland that had been installed by the Soviet Union "on a broader democratic basis."
▪   The Polish eastern border would follow the Curzon Line, and Poland would receive territorial compensation in the West from Germany.
▪   Churchill alone pushed for free elections in Poland. The British leader pointed out that the UK "could never be content with any solution that did not leave Poland a free and independent state". Stalin pledged to permit free elections in Poland, but forestalled ever honouring his promise.
▪   Citizens of the Soviet Union and of Yugoslavia were to be handed over to their respective countries, regardless of their consent.
▪   Roosevelt obtained a commitment by Stalin to participate in the UN.
▪   Stalin requested that all of the 16 Soviet Socialist Republics would be granted UN membership. This was taken into consideration, but 14 republics were denied.
▪   Stalin agreed to enter the fight against the Empire of Japan within 90 days after the defeat of Germany.
▪   Nazi war criminals were to be hunted down and brought to justice.
A "Committee on Dismemberment of Germany" was to be set up. Its purpose was to decide whether Germany was to be divided into six nations.
The Big Three also agreed that all original governments would be restored to the invaded countries (with the exception of the French government, which was regarded as collaborationist; in Romania and Bulgaria, where the Soviets had already liquidated most of the governments, the Polish government-in-exile was also excluded by Stalin) and that all civilians would be repatriated.

As can be noted, Stalin exerted considerable influence, much to the regret of Western politicians. It has taken a while to recover from the effects of the various conferences that took place, first at Tehran (1943), then Yalta, and next at Potsdam in July of 1945.

Hughes
And finally on the 4th February 2004 Facebook was founded by Mark Zuckerberg, Dustin Moskovitz,  Chris Hughes and  Eduardo P. Saverin. All very rich young men.
Zuckerberg
Moskovitz






Saverin

Friday, 3 February 2012

WIND OF CHANGE AND THE FAMILY SILVER

The 3rd February signals an interesting performance writer/speaker. Some of his remarks have had an extraordinary impact on world as well as local affairs. On the 3rd February 1960, British Prime Minister Harold Macmillan made a speech to the Parliament of South Africa, It turned out to be an historical address. He had spent a month in Africa visiting a number of British colonies, as they were at the time. The speech signalled clearly that the Conservative-controlled British Government intended to grant independence to many of these territories, which indeed happened subsequently, with most of the British possessions in Africa becoming independent nations in the 1960s. The Labour governments of 1945–51 had started a process of decolonisation but this policy had been halted by the Conservative governments from 1951 onwards.
The speech acquired its name, The Wind of Change speech, from a now-famous quotation embedded in it. Macmillan said:
The wind of change is blowing through this continent. Whether we like it or not, this growth of national consciousness is a political fact.
Macmillan's Cape Town speech made it clear that Macmillan included South Africa in his comments and indicated a shift in British policy in regard to apartheid with Macmillan saying:
As a fellow member of the Commonwealth it is our earnest desire to give South Africa our support and encouragement, but I hope you won't mind my saying frankly that there are some aspects of your policies which make it impossible for us to do this without being false to our own deep convictions about the political destinies of free men to which in our own territories we are trying to give effect.

The occasion was in fact the second time on which Macmillan had given this speech: he was repeating an address already made in Accra, Ghana, (formerly the British colony of the Gold Coast) on 10 January 1960. This time it received press attention, at least partly because of the stony reception that greeted it. It is noteworthy that the context of the speech made such a difference. The repeat performance given just 24 days later to an inflexible silent group of white supremacist made much greater impact.
As to performance, besides restarting the policy of decolonisation, the speech marked political shifts that were to occur within the next year or so, in the Union of South Africa and the United Kingdom. The formation of the Republic of South Africa in 1961 and the country's departure from the Commonwealth of Nations were the result of a number of factors, but the change in the UK's attitude to African self-government is usually considered to have been significant.
There was an extended backlash against the speech from the right of the Conservative Party, which wished Britain to retain its imperial possessions. The speech led directly to the formation of the Conservative Monday Club pressure group.
In later life Macmillan made a couple of other comments that reverberated in the UK during the ‘reign’ of Margaret Thatcher. Of the miner’s strike he said, in the House of Lords:
It breaks my heart to see—and I cannot interfere—what is happening in our country today. This terrible strike, by the best men in the world, who beat the Kaiser’s's and Hitler’s's armies and never gave in. It is pointless and we cannot afford that kind of thing. Then there is the growing division of Conservative prosperity in the south and the ailing north and Midlands. We used to have battles and rows but they were quarrels. Now there is a new kind of wicked hatred that has been brought in by different types of people.
And also as regards her monetarist policies

'First of all the Georgian silver goes. And then all that nice furniture that used to be in the salon. Then the Canalettos go.'

Well he was a bit of a toff, but not a bad performance writer.

Wednesday, 1 February 2012

WHEN WILL WE MAKE AN END?


On the 1st February 1865, President Abraham Lincoln signed the Thirteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution. It is a very short amendment:

Section 1. Neither slavery nor involuntary servitude, except as a punishment for crime whereof the party shall have been duly convicted, shall exist within the United States, or any place subject to their jurisdiction.
Section 2. Congress shall have power to enforce this article by appropriate legislation.

The Thirteenth Amendment's archival copy bears an apparent Presidential signature, under the usual ones of the Speaker of the House and the President of the Senate, after the words "Approved February 1, 1865". Lincoln was assassinated 73 days later on the 15th April 1865.

It is noteworthy that the act does not prohibit the imposition of slavery or involuntary servitude for those convicted of a crime. Any crime will do.

Ninety five years later, to the day, on the 1st February 1960 four students from the Agricultural and Technical College of North Carolina sat down at the lunch counter inside the Woolworth's store at 132 South Elm Street in Greensboro, North Carolina. The men, later known as the Greensboro Four, ordered coffee. Following store policy, the lunch counter staff refused to serve the African American men at the "whites only" counter and the store's manager asked them to leave. The four university freshmen – Joseph McNeil, Franklin McCain, Ezell Blair, Jr. (later known as Jibreel Khazan), and David Richmond – stayed until the store closed. This was not an easy thing to do, given the nature of white America at the time.


And on the 1st February 1968, in Vietnam, National Police Chief Nguyen Ngoc Loan is videotaped and photographed by photojournalist Eddie Adams, in the act of ‘executing’ an alleged Viet Cong officer Nguyen Van Lem. It is one of the most brutal episodes of that war and the picture still provokes outrage and disgust. The impact of the photograph, its performance, was almost immediate and contributed to  a hastening of growing support in opposition to the Vietnam War.
Since that picture, Adams has had second thoughts about its effect. On Nguyen Ngoc Loan and his famous photograph, Adams wrote in Time:
The general killed the Viet Cong; I killed the general with my camera. Still photographs are the most powerful weapon in the world. People believe them; but photographs do lie, even without manipulation. They are only half-truths. ... What the photograph didn't say was, 'What would you do if you were the general at that time and place on that hot day, and you caught the so-called bad guy after he blew away one, two or three American people?

I believe he may have a point about the performance of still photographs; however, in my submission, this is a rather sad statement. Summary, brutal and public execution is NEVER acceptable. This attitude of good guys and bad guys still infects society like an incurable virus. It may be OK for kids to play at cowboys, but it should be left behind with childhood. Perhaps the only way to get rid of it is not to play it anymore. This attitude is what permits men to feel they are entitled to operate outside the rule of law, with the excuse that it’s OK to take revenge on the bad guy. This ignorance still permeates our culture. It is an attitude reflected over one hundred years ago in the 13th Amendment – if you commit a crime, you can be made a slave.  How can one in the same breath exhort that slavery is evil on the one hand, but acquiesce in its inflictment as a punishment on the other. What sort of reasoning is that? It is the sort of reasoning that leads to summary, brutal public executions. For a while the public is appalled, but when will we make an end?