I find identity theory keeps expanding rather like
the universe after the big bang. Various sources deal with types of identity
theories of mind.
Type
physicalism (also known
as reductive materialism, type identity theory, mind-brain
identity theory and identity theory of mind) is a physicalist
theory, in philosophy of mind. It asserts that mental events can be grouped
into types, and can then be correlated with types of physical events in
the brain. For example, one type of mental event like "mental
pains" will, presumably, turn out to be describing one type of
physical event (like C-fibre firings).
C fibres
are found in the nerves of the somatic sensory system. They are afferent fibres,
conveying input signals from the periphery to the central nervous system. C fibres
are unmyelinated unlike most other fibres in the nervous system. This lack of
myelination is the cause of their slow conduction velocity, which is on the
order of no more than 2 m/s. C fibres are on average 0.2 - 1.5 µm in diameter.
Type physicalism is
contrasted by token identity
physicalism. Token identity physicalism argues that mental events are
unlikely to have "steady" or categorical biological correlates. These
positions make use of the philosophical Type-token distinction (e.g. having the
same type of car need not mean that you and your friend share a token,
a single vehicle). Type physicalism can now be understood to argue that
there is identicalness between types, whereas token identity physicalism
says we are only describing a particular, unique, brain event.
And from another source:
Type identity theory, or type
physicalism is the theory that brain activity and corresponding mental
processes are type-identical. The term type in this version of
identity theory is meant to signify a difference between type and token, in
which type is a category and token is an instance of a member of that category.
For instance, the phrase “bigger and bigger and bigger” contains two types of
words (the types being “bigger” and “and”) and five tokens (three tokens of the
type “bigger” and two tokens of the type “and”). So, activity in a specific
type of tissue or area of the brain may correspond with pleasure, making
pleasure and that brain activity type-identical.
Token Physicalism / Token
Identity
Token identity from type
identity in that the relationship between a physical and mental event is more
specific to the event. A specific token of a physical occurrence in the brain
corresponds with a specific token of a mental activity. Token identity theory more
broadly states that mental and physical processes generally refer to the same
thing, though they need not be necessarily of a specific type on either side.
Token physicalism is, in essence, the same as property
dualism which holds that mental properties of the brain (mental
tokens) correspond with physical properties of the brain (physical tokens) —
both of which are analogous to each other and refer to the same physical object,
but which differ ontologically in that mental processes are of a different
quality than their physical counterparts.
There are 3 other parts -
No comments:
Post a Comment